WHY IS A PLUMBER? (McCarey, 1929)

Two-reel silent short — 20 mins.
Hal Roach Studios (distributed by MGM) / Dir. Leo McCarey

Production: December 13, 1928 — December 18, 1928
Release date: March 30, 1929
Survival/release status: Unknown (likely lost, no known archive holdings as of 2026).

Cast: Edgar Kennedy, Gertrude Sutton, Albert Conti, Eddie Dunn, Jean Harlow.

Summary (from the Iowa City Press-Citizen, June 1929): “This hilarious bit of foolishness has for its theme the gradual rise of a hard-working plumber and his wife, who, after years of struggle, find themselves with a lovely home. The wife who has social aspirations and a desire to entertain people of wealth and note, invites a millionaire couple to dinner. She hires a caterer to help her with the serving and they send a butler who turns out to be a truck driver with whom her husband has had a collision, a short time before, which resulted in a street fight. What these two do when they recognize each other and what happened to the millionaire couple has to be seen to be appreciated.”

Stills and ad art:

Jean Harlow in a publicity portrait for Why Is a Plumber?